The summary of ‘"E-ATX" Is A Lie: How Motherboard Makers Ruined Form Factors’

This summary of the video was created by an AI. It might contain some inaccuracies.

00:00:0000:22:02

The YouTube video discusses the confusion and lack of standardization in motherboard form factors, focusing on ATX and its variations like E-ATX and E-ITX. It explores the history and evolution of ATX as the industry standard and the challenges consumers face in component compatibility. The importance of adhering to form factor standards, particularly in relation to XL ATX and EATX, is highlighted. The video emphasizes the need for clarity in labeling to ensure compatibility between motherboards and cases, addressing the complexities and confusion surrounding different form factors. Case manufacturers' inconsistent EATX support and the importance of defining dimensions over ambiguous form-factor names are also discussed. The video criticizes manufacturers for not adhering to standard dimensions and highlights the difficulties consumers face due to inconsistencies in form factors. A call is made for manufacturers to follow standard dimensions like SSI EEB to avoid confusion and ensure compatibility.

00:00:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker discusses the confusion and lack of standardization in motherboard form factors, particularly focusing on ATX and its variations like E-ATX and E-ITX. The speaker criticizes motherboard manufacturers for not adhering to standard dimensions, leading to compatibility issues with cases. The video also delves into the history of ATX as a standard released by Intel in 1995 to replace the IBM 80 form factor. The importance of following specs and avoiding custom form factors is emphasized, highlighting the challenges consumers face in selecting compatible components.

00:03:00

In this segment of the video, the focus is on the evolution of PC motherboard form factors, particularly the ATX standard. The ATX form factor has been the industry standard since 1984 and has resisted Intel’s attempts to replace it with newer standards like BTX. ATX specifications define various aspects of motherboards and power supplies for uniformity across the industry. The video discusses variations like E-ATX (Extended ATX) and XL-ATX, highlighting their dimensions and differences. Despite some companies introducing their versions like EE-ATX and XL-ATX, the standard ATX remains prevalent. This segment emphasizes the importance of adhering to form factor standards for compatibility in PC building.

00:06:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker discusses the XL ATX form factor for motherboards, noting that the increase in popularity of power supply shrouds has made XL ATX less common. XL ATX boards are taller, allowing for more room for things like chipset cooling and extra PCIe slots, primarily useful for multi-GPU setups. However, the XL ATX form factor has been mostly replaced by boards that increase in width rather than height, known as EATX. The segment also touches on the confusion surrounding EATX terminology, differences between EATX and EE B form factors, and the history of EATX as a marketing term possibly originating from Asus.

00:09:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker explains the confusion around the term E-ATX, which is not an official specification but rather a marketing term indicating a motherboard wider than 9.6 inches. They highlight that SSI EEB boards use the same hole placement as ATX with some extra holes added. The segment emphasizes the need for clarity in labeling to ensure compatibility between motherboards and cases, touching on the complexities surrounding E-ATX and SSI EEB boards.

00:12:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker explains the alternative SSI EE B holes that some motherboard manufacturers use in place of traditional ATX locations. These alternate holes provide more flexibility in component placement but may limit compatibility with ATX standards and cases. The speaker discusses the confusion around the interchangeability of EA TX and EB boards due to varying hole placements. Manufacturers may skip mounting holes but cannot add new ones. The video highlights the proliferation of different motherboard form factors and how case manufacturers adjust to accommodate them, leading to the need for standards. Various consumer cases and their described maximum motherboard size compatibility are detailed, emphasizing the discrepancies and lack of standardization among different manufacturers.

00:15:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker discusses the confusion around defining case sizes, particularly concerning EATX compatibility. Many case manufacturers claim EATX support, but specifications are vague, leading to inconsistencies in actual compatibility. The need for separately purchased parts to accommodate 13-inch boards is criticized. The speaker suggests simply listing the dimensions of cases rather than using ambiguous form-factor names. The lack of consistency in case design limits compatibility with wider boards, despite potential space for adjustments. The removal of drive cages has created space for wider motherboards, but proper accommodation remains a challenge in case designs.

00:18:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker discusses issues with ATX support in cases, particularly criticizing EVGA for not designing cases around ATX boards. The speaker has faced difficulties fitting EVGA motherboards into standard cases and mentions specific problematic models like SRX, ax 299 dark, and SR3. They highlight the inconsistency in form factors and urge manufacturers to adhere to standard dimensions like SSI EEB to avoid confusion. The speaker emphasizes the importance of clarity in defining motherboard sizes to ensure compatibility and ease of use for customers.

00:21:00

In this part of the video, the speaker emphasizes the importance of customer opinion over industry-defined terms like SSI EE. They suggest viewers share their thoughts on the matter. They note the confusion among manufacturers regarding form factors and criticize companies like CSUN EVGA for complicating the issue. The speaker encourages viewers to subscribe for more content and support them through their website or Patreon.

Scroll to Top