The summary of ‘Costco Kirkland's vs Purina Pro Plan (Dog food Review)’

This summary of the video was created by an AI. It might contain some inaccuracies.

00:00:0000:14:42

The video compares Kirkland's lamb and rice adult dog food with Purina Pro Plan lamb and rice. Various aspects are examined, including nutritional content, ingredient manipulation, and suitability for different life stages of pets. Both products are critiqued for their calcium and phosphorus levels and potential allergy concerns. The importance of reading ingredient lists carefully is emphasized, with a preference towards Pro Plan due to better meeting nutritional requirements, despite being pricier. The conclusion suggests consulting a veterinarian for specific dietary needs and favoring Pro Plan if choosing between the two options.

00:00:00

In this part of the video, the presenter discusses comparing Kirkland’s lemon rice dog food from Costco with Purina Pro Plan lemon rice. They explore the Kirkland Signature Adult Formula Lamb and Rice dog food, highlighting its label claims, such as containing glucosamine and vitamin E. The presenter notes the absence of an AAFCO statement on the website, indicating viewers would need to check the bag in person. The focus is on evaluating the food’s suitability for adult dogs and analyzing its guaranteed analysis.

00:03:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker discusses a dog food’s nutritional content, specifically focusing on calcium, phosphorus, protein, fat, and fiber levels. The speaker received quick and helpful customer service when inquiring about the calcium and phosphorus content. They mention that the phosphorus and calcium levels in the dog food are higher than ideal which could be a concern for dogs with kidney issues. The speaker also talks about the ingredients listing lamb as the main ingredient and explains the weight of ingredients in dry dog food compared to raw materials. They express disappointment about the lack of information on the AFCO statement on the packaging.

00:06:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker discusses how ingredients in pet food can be manipulated in the ingredient list. They mention that even though lamb is listed as the first ingredient, the actual amount of lamb in the product may be less due to processing. The concept of grain splitting is explained, where rice is split into smaller components to manipulate its placement on the ingredient list. The importance of reading ingredient lists carefully is emphasized, as products like the one being discussed may contain other ingredients like chicken fat, which could be problematic for pets with allergies. The speaker also compares the analyzed product with Purina Pro Plan Lamb and Rice, pointing out factors like cost and potential suitability for different life stages of pets.

00:09:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker compares two dog foods, Kirkland’s lamb and rice formula and Purina Pro Plan all life stages. They mention that both foods are all life stages, suitable for all ages, with the Pro Plan listing protein at 27%, fat at 17%, fiber at 3%, calcium at 1.1%, and phosphorus at 0.9%. The speaker notes that both foods are slightly above the reference range for calcium and phosphorus, with the Pro Plan being slightly better for adult dogs compared to puppies or pregnant/lactating dogs. The comparison also touches on the ingredients, emphasizing that lamb is the first ingredient in both formulas.

00:12:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker discusses a pet food product containing lamb, rice, corn gluten meal, beef fat, and fish meal. The diet includes multiple protein sources, making it unsuitable for pets with allergies. The speaker recommends consulting a veterinarian for a more restricted diet if needed. Comparing two products, the speaker suggests the Pro Plan as it meets calcium and phosphorus requirements better, despite being pricier. While neither product aligns perfectly with all life stages, the Pro Plan is favored if limited to choosing between the two options.