The summary of ‘Which Echo Show Should You Buy? || Echo Show 5 vs Echo Show 8 vs Echo Show 10’

This summary of the video was created by an AI. It might contain some inaccuracies.

00:00:0000:26:26

In the video, Brian from "Automate Your Life" provides an in-depth comparison of Amazon Echo Show models, namely the Echo Show 5, 8, and 10. He evaluates their screen quality, speaker capabilities, and optimal placement to ensure the best sound performance. Key differences are highlighted, such as the higher pixel density of the Echo Show 5 and the superior audio quality and screen rotation features of the Echo Show 10. Important features like video content accessibility via Amazon's Silk browser, consistent accessibility functions, and the importance of proper device placement for sound quality are discussed.

A notable aspect is the differing power supplies and the Echo Show 10's Amazon AZ1 neural processor, which boosts AI and machine learning functionalities. The integration with smart home technologies, including Amazon Sidewalk and Zigbee hub functionalities, and their implications for home automation and security are covered. Additionally, Brian discusses power consumption, camera features, and advanced functionality like auto-framing during video calls.

The Echo Show devices support a variety of smart home controls, productivity features, and media services, but the Echo Show 8 is recommended as the best value for video content consumption. The overall conclusion emphasizes understanding both the similarities and distinctions of these devices to make an informed purchase decision.

00:00:00

In this part of the video, the host Brian from Automate Your Life compares different Amazon Echo Show models, emphasizing that despite being named for their screen sizes, there are significant variations in features beyond just size and speakers. He introduces seven indices for comparing the devices, with time codes available for easy navigation. The Echo Show 5 is noted for its high pixel density at 195 pixels per inch, compared to the Echo Show 8’s 188 and the Echo Show 10’s 149, though this difference doesn’t significantly impact content quality. All models offer the same video content and interface, accessible via Amazon’s voice assistant. For YouTube, they rely on Amazon’s Silk browser with both onscreen typing and voice search capabilities. Accessibility features such as closed captioning and color blindness adjustments are consistent across all three models.

00:03:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker evaluates various Echo Show devices in terms of their screen quality, speaker capabilities, and optimal placement for sound quality. The Echo Show 10 is shown playing Prime Video with high-quality closed captions, while the Echo Show 8, playing Netflix, displays a reduced screen size. The Echo Show 5 is demonstrated using a YouTube video.

Additionally, the speaker discusses an action of turning on a bulb and makes a recommendation for the Echo Show 8 as the best value for video content consumption. They also highlight the most common use of these speakers, which is for audio content. The segment provides detailed information on the speaker configurations for the Echo Show 5, 8, and 10, advising on their optimal placement in the home to ensure the best sound quality.

00:06:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker discusses the physical placement of Echo Show devices to achieve optimal sound quality. They explain that incorrect placement can lead to muffled sound and recommend positioning the devices near reflective surfaces. The loudness of various Echo Show models is measured, with the Echo Show 5 reaching 112 decibels, and both the Echo Show 8 and 10 achieving 117 decibels. The Echo Show 8 and 10 offer better performance at a distance, maintaining up to 97 decibels, whereas the Echo Show 5 drops to 81 decibels. The segment also covers that services like audiobooks, podcasts, and music are consistent across all devices, and mentions that Echo Show speakers no longer support being used as speakers for Fire TV sticks, recommending Echo or Echo Studio instead.

00:09:00

In this segment of the video, the speaker compares the Echo Show 10, Echo Show 8, and Echo Show 5 in terms of audio quality, screen rotation, and physical design aspects that impact usability. The Echo Show 10 is highlighted as having superior audio quality and a notable screen rotation feature. However, its 175-degree rotation requires a significant footprint (10 inches in diameter) within a home, which can be limiting. The Echo Show 8 and Echo Show 5 are more compact, needing only 4 and 3 inches of space, respectively. Height differences also affect their placement flexibility. Additionally, the Echo Show 10 has the best microphone pickup due to having multiple microphones positioned around the device, enhancing its ability to hear commands from any direction.

00:12:00

In this part of the video, the presenter discusses the differences between various Echo Show devices, focusing primarily on the absence of the 3.5mm output jack in the new models, which was present in older generations. They also highlight differences in power supplies, noting that the Echo Show 5 uses a 15-watt power supply whereas the Echo Show 8 and 10 use a 30-watt power supply. The Echo Show 10 stands out because it features the Amazon AZ1 neural processor designed to improve AI and machine learning capabilities over time. All devices require Wi-Fi for most functionalities and share identical Bluetooth connectivity capabilities. The segment also briefly explains Amazon Sidewalk, a technology enabling extended smart home device reach beyond typical home boundaries.

00:15:00

In this part of the video, the discussion revolves around the integration of Amazon’s Echo devices with security and smart home technologies, specifically highlighting the significance of Amazon Sidewalk and Zigbee hub functionalities. Amazon’s Echo devices, such as the fourth-generation Echo, can now serve as a Ring Bridge, eliminating the need for an additional smart home hub. Amazon Sidewalk enables notifications from smart home cameras even without internet connectivity. Furthermore, the Echo Show 10 includes a Zigbee hub, allowing direct connection to Zigbee-compatible devices like motion sensors and light switches, thus removing the need for additional hubs like Samsung SmartThings. The narrator also touches on additional costs beyond the purchase price, such as Amazon Prime subscriptions for enhanced services and operational costs including power consumption.

00:18:00

In this part of the video, the speaker discusses the power consumption of Echo Show devices. They highlight that the screen uses minimal power (0.4 watts), but the speaker is the most significant power draw. Tests were conducted with the microphone, camera, and screen turned off while playing music via Bluetooth to measure power usage at different volumes. Surprisingly, the Echo Show 8 uses more power at 100% volume than the Echo Show 10 and Echo Show 5. Additionally, the cameras on Echo Show devices vary, with the Echo Show 5 having a 2-megapixel camera, while the Echo Show 8 and 10 feature superior 13-megapixel cameras. Enhanced video calling capabilities with auto framing and optional screen rotation features are also discussed.

00:21:00

In this part of the video, the larger megapixel cameras on the Echo Show 10 and Echo Show 8 enable advanced automation in homes, such as creating routines that can detect people and save power by turning off screens when rooms are empty. However, these features do not work in the dark. These devices can also function as home security cameras and baby monitors, with capabilities to view the video feed through the Amazon app and beta features like detecting a crying baby.

For video calling, all three Echo Show devices support calls between Amazon smart displays, but only the Echo Show 8 and 10 support Zoom (with regional restrictions). The Echo Show 5 lacks Zoom functionality, likely due to its smaller size. Additionally, all three devices allow taking and sending photos or videos and reacting to messages through the Amazon app.

The video emphasizes understanding both the similarities and differences of these devices while choosing one to purchase and invites viewers to ask any remaining questions they might have.

00:24:00

In this part of the video, the speaker addresses common features across various Amazon Echo devices. They highlight that all these devices come with the same voice assistant, can have celebrity voices, and can be called different names. The response speed is generally consistent due to the same main processor, but future improvements may come with the AZ1 processor. All devices support the same productivity features such as connecting to calendars, creating custom lists, setting timers, and managing them on-screen. They facilitate smart home control, access to news, podcasts, and other information services, and enable Amazon shopping and account integration. Region-specific features like Amazon Guard and the energy dashboard are also available. Lastly, the speaker offers links for purchase and a playlist for more detailed reviews and comparisons.

Scroll to Top